When flushing the cache, we create a new cache database. The serve-stale
settings need to be restored after doing this. We already did this
for max-stale-ttl, but forgot to do this for stale-refresh-time.
The isc_stats_create() can no longer return anything else than
ISC_R_SUCCESS. Refactor isc_stats_create() and its variants in libdns,
libns and named to just return void.
to reduce the amount of common code that will need to be shared
between the separated cache and zone database implementations,
clean up unused portions of dns_db.
the methods dns_db_dump(), dns_db_isdnssec(), dns_db_printnode(),
dns_db_resigned(), dns_db_expirenode() and dns_db_overmem() were
either never called or were only implemented as nonoperational stub
functions: they have now been removed.
dns_db_nodefullname() was only used in one place, which turned out
to be unnecessary, so it has also been removed.
dns_db_ispersistent() and dns_db_transfernode() are used, but only
the default implementation in db.c was ever actually called. since
they were never overridden by database methods, there's no need to
retain methods for them.
in rbtdb.c, beginload() and endload() methods are no longer defined for
the cache database, because that was never used (except in a few unit
tests which can easily be modified to use the zone implementation
instead). issecure() is also no longer defined for the cache database,
as the cache is always insecure and the default implementation of
dns_db_issecure() returns false.
for similar reasons, hashsize() is no longer defined for zone databases.
implementation functions that are shared between zone and cache are now
prepended with 'dns__rbtdb_' so they can become nonstatic.
serve_stale_ttl is now a common member of dns_db.
The total memory counter had again little or no meaning when we removed
the internal memory allocator. It was just a monotonic counter that
would count add the allocation sizes but never subtracted anything, so
it would be just a "big number".
The maxinuse memory counter indicated the highest amount of
memory allocated in the past. Checking and updating this high-
water mark value every time memory was allocated had an impact
on server performance, so it has been removed. Memory size can
be monitored more efficiently via an external tool logging RSS.
'DNS_DB_STALEOK' returns stale rdatasets as well as current rdatasets.
'DNS_DB_EXPIREDOK' returns expired rdatasets as well as current
rdatasets. This option is currently only set when DNS_DB_STALEOK is
also set.
The mechanism for associating a worker task to a database now
uses loops rather than tasks.
For this reason, the parameters to dns_cache_create() have been
updated to take a loop manager rather than a task manager.
The dns_cache API contained a cache cleaning mechanism that would be
disabled for 'rbt' based cache. As named doesn't have any other cache
implementations, remove the cache cleaning mechanism from dns_cache API.
Mostly generated automatically with the following semantic patch,
except where coccinelle was confused by #ifdef in lib/isc/net.c
@@ expression list args; @@
- UNEXPECTED_ERROR(__FILE__, __LINE__, args)
+ UNEXPECTED_ERROR(args)
@@ expression list args; @@
- FATAL_ERROR(__FILE__, __LINE__, args)
+ FATAL_ERROR(args)
Previously:
* applications were using isc_app as the base unit for running the
application and signal handling.
* networking was handled in the netmgr layer, which would start a
number of threads, each with a uv_loop event loop.
* task/event handling was done in the isc_task unit, which used
netmgr event loops to run the isc_event calls.
In this refactoring:
* the network manager now uses isc_loop instead of maintaining its
own worker threads and event loops.
* the taskmgr that manages isc_task instances now also uses isc_loopmgr,
and every isc_task runs on a specific isc_loop bound to the specific
thread.
* applications have been updated as necessary to use the new API.
* new ISC_LOOP_TEST macros have been added to enable unit tests to
run isc_loop event loops. unit tests have been updated to use this
where needed.
* isc_timer was rewritten using the uv_timer, and isc_timermgr_t was
completely removed; isc_timer objects are now directly created on the
isc_loop event loops.
* the isc_timer API has been simplified. the "inactive" timer type has
been removed; timers are now stopped by calling isc_timer_stop()
instead of resetting to inactive.
* isc_manager now creates a loop manager rather than a timer manager.
* modules and applications using isc_timer have been updated to use the
new API.
Previously, tasks could be created either unbound or bound to a specific
thread (worker loop). The unbound tasks would be assigned to a random
thread every time isc_task_send() was called. Because there's no logic
that would assign the task to the least busy worker, this just creates
unpredictability. Instead of random assignment, bind all the previously
unbound tasks to worker 0, which is guaranteed to exist.
After removing the isc_task_onshutdown(), the isc_task_shutdown() and
isc_task_destroy() became obsolete.
Remove calls to isc_task_shutdown() and replace the calls to
isc_task_destroy() with isc_task_detach().
Simplify the internal logic to destroy the task when the last reference
is removed.
The isc_task_onshutdown() was used to post event that should be run when
the task is being shutdown. This could happen explicitly in the
isc_test_shutdown() call or implicitly when we detach the last reference
to the task and there are no more events posted on the task.
This whole task onshutdown mechanism just makes things more complicated,
and it's easier to post the "shutdown" events when we are shutting down
explicitly and the existing code already always knows when it should
shutdown the task that's being used to execute the onshutdown events.
Replace the isc_task_onshutdown() calls with explicit calls to execute
the shutdown tasks.
Historically, the inline keyword was a strong suggestion to the compiler
that it should inline the function marked inline. As compilers became
better at optimising, this functionality has receded, and using inline
as a suggestion to inline a function is obsolete. The compiler will
happily ignore it and inline something else entirely if it finds that's
a better optimisation.
Therefore, remove all the occurences of the inline keyword with static
functions inside single compilation unit and leave the decision whether
to inline a function or not entirely on the compiler
NOTE: We keep the usage the inline keyword when the purpose is to change
the linkage behaviour.
This commit converts the license handling to adhere to the REUSE
specification. It specifically:
1. Adds used licnses to LICENSES/ directory
2. Add "isc" template for adding the copyright boilerplate
3. Changes all source files to include copyright and SPDX license
header, this includes all the C sources, documentation, zone files,
configuration files. There are notes in the doc/dev/copyrights file
on how to add correct headers to the new files.
4. Handle the rest that can't be modified via .reuse/dep5 file. The
binary (or otherwise unmodifiable) files could have license places
next to them in <foo>.license file, but this would lead to cluttered
repository and most of the files handled in the .reuse/dep5 file are
system test files.
dns_db_nodecount can now be used to get counts from the auxilary
rbt databases. The existing node count is returned by
tree=dns_dbtree_main. The nsec and nsec3 node counts by dns_dbtree_nsec
and dns_dbtree_nsec3 respectively.
Note when synthesising answer involving wildcards we look in the
cache multiple times, once for the QNAME and once for the wildcard
name which is constucted by looking at the names from the covering
NSEC return by the QNAME miss.
Originally, the hash table used in RBT database would be resized when it
reached certain number of elements (defined by overcommit). This was
causing resolution brownouts for busy resolvers, because the rehashing
could take several seconds to complete. This was mitigated by
pre-allocating the hash table in the RBT database used for caching to be
large-enough as determined by max-cache-size. The downside of this
solution was that the pre-allocated hash table could take a significant
chunk of the memory even when the resolver cache would be otherwise
empty because the default value for max-cache-size is 90% of available
memory.
Implement incremental resizing[1] to perform the rehashing gradually:
1. During the resize, allocate the new hash table, but keep the old
table unchanged.
2. In each lookup or delete operation, check both tables.
3. Perform insertion operations only in the new table.
4. At each insertion also move r elements from the old table to the new
table.
5. When all elements are removed from the old table, deallocate it.
To ensure that the old table is completely copied over before the new
table itself needs to be enlarged, it is necessary to increase the
size of the table by a factor of at least (r + 1)/r during resizing.
In our implementation r is equal to 1.
The downside of this approach is that the old table and the new table
could stay in memory for longer when there are no new insertions into
the hash table for prolonged periods of time as the incremental
rehashing happens only during the insertions.
The upside of this approach is that it's no longer necessary to
pre-allocate large hash table, because the RBT hash table rehashing
doesn't cause resolution brownouts anymore and thus we can use the
memory as needed.
1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hash_table#Dynamic_resizing
Remove the dynamic registration of result codes. Convert isc_result_t
from unsigned + #defines into 32-bit enum type in grand unified
<isc/result.h> header. Keep the existing values of the result codes
even at the expense of the description and identifier tables being
unnecessary large.
Additionally, add couple of:
switch (result) {
[...]
default:
break;
}
statements where compiler now complains about missing enum values in the
switch statement.
as libdns is no longer exported, it's not necessary to have
init and shutdown functions. the only purpose they served
was to create a private mctx and run dst_lib_init(), which
can be called directly instead.
"cache-file" was already documented as intended for testing
purposes only and not to be used, so we can remove it without
waiting. this commit marks the option as "ancient", and
removes all the documentation and implementing code, including
dns_cache_setfilename() and dns_cache_dump().
it also removes the documentation for the '-x cachefile`
parameter to named, which had already been removed, but the man
page was not updated at the time.
On the isc_mem water change the old water_t structure could be used
after free. Instead of introducing reference counting on the hot-path
we are going to introduce additional constraints on the
isc_mem_setwater. Once it's set for the first time, the additional
calls have to be made with the same water and water_arg arguments.
The proper way how to disable the water limit in the isc_mem context is
to call:
isc_mem_setwater(ctx, NULL, NULL, 0, 0);
this ensures that the old water callback is called with ISC_MEM_LOWATER
if the callback was called with ISC_MEM_HIWATER before.
Historically, there were some places where the limits were disabled by
calling:
isc_mem_setwater(ctx, water, water_arg, 0, 0);
which would also call the old callback, but it also causes the water_t
to be allocated and extra check to be executed because water callback is
not NULL.
This commits unifies the calls to disable water to the preferred form.
When "max-cache-size" is changed to "unlimited" (or "0") for a running
named instance (using "rndc reconfig"), the hash table size limit for
each affected cache DB is not reset to the maximum possible value,
preventing those hash tables from being allowed to grow as a result of
new nodes being added.
Extend dns_rbt_adjusthashsize() to interpret "size" set to 0 as a signal
to remove any previously imposed limits on the hash table size. Adjust
API documentation for dns_db_adjusthashsize() accordingly. Move the
call to dns_db_adjusthashsize() from dns_cache_setcachesize() so that it
also happens when "size" is set to 0.
Before this update, BIND would attempt to do a full recursive resolution
process for each query received if the requested rrset had its ttl
expired. If the resolution fails for any reason, only then BIND would
check for stale rrset in cache (if 'stale-cache-enable' and
'stale-answer-enable' is on).
The problem with this approach is that if an authoritative server is
unreachable or is failing to respond, it is very unlikely that the
problem will be fixed in the next seconds.
A better approach to improve performance in those cases, is to mark the
moment in which a resolution failed, and if new queries arrive for that
same rrset, try to respond directly from the stale cache, and do that
for a window of time configured via 'stale-refresh-time'.
Only when this interval expires we then try to do a normal refresh of
the rrset.
The logic behind this commit is as following:
- In query.c / query_gotanswer(), if the test of 'result' variable falls
to the default case, an error is assumed to have happened, and a call
to 'query_usestale()' is made to check if serving of stale rrset is
enabled in configuration.
- If serving of stale answers is enabled, a flag will be turned on in
the query context to look for stale records:
query.c:6839
qctx->client->query.dboptions |= DNS_DBFIND_STALEOK;
- A call to query_lookup() will be made again, inside it a call to
'dns_db_findext()' is made, which in turn will invoke rbdb.c /
cache_find().
- In rbtdb.c / cache_find() the important bits of this change is the
call to 'check_stale_header()', which is a function that yields true
if we should skip the stale entry, or false if we should consider it.
- In check_stale_header() we now check if the DNS_DBFIND_STALEOK option
is set, if that is the case we know that this new search for stale
records was made due to a failure in a normal resolution, so we keep
track of the time in which the failured occured in rbtdb.c:4559:
header->last_refresh_fail_ts = search->now;
- In check_stale_header(), if DNS_DBFIND_STALEOK is not set, then we
know this is a normal lookup, if the record is stale and the query
time is between last failure time + stale-refresh-time window, then
we return false so cache_find() knows it can consider this stale
rrset entry to return as a response.
The last additions are two new methods to the database interface:
- setservestale_refresh
- getservestale_refresh
Those were added so rbtdb can be aware of the value set in configuration
option, since in that level we have no access to the view object.
Created isc_refcount_decrement_expect macro to test conditionally
the return value to ensure it is in expected range. Converted
unchecked isc_refcount_decrement to use isc_refcount_decrement_expect.
Converted INSIST(isc_refcount_decrement()...) to isc_refcount_decrement_expect.
There were several problems with rbt hashtable implementation:
1. Our internal hashing function returns uint64_t value, but it was
silently truncated to unsigned int in dns_name_hash() and
dns_name_fullhash() functions. As the SipHash 2-4 higher bits are
more random, we need to use the upper half of the return value.
2. The hashtable implementation in rbt.c was using modulo to pick the
slot number for the hash table. This has several problems because
modulo is: a) slow, b) oblivious to patterns in the input data. This
could lead to very uneven distribution of the hashed data in the
hashtable. Combined with the single-linked lists we use, it could
really hog-down the lookup and removal of the nodes from the rbt
tree[a]. The Fibonacci Hashing is much better fit for the hashtable
function here. For longer description, read "Fibonacci Hashing: The
Optimization that the World Forgot"[b] or just look at the Linux
kernel. Also this will make Diego very happy :).
3. The hashtable would rehash every time the number of nodes in the rbt
tree would exceed 3 * (hashtable size). The overcommit will make the
uneven distribution in the hashtable even worse, but the main problem
lies in the rehashing - every time the database grows beyond the
limit, each subsequent rehashing will be much slower. The mitigation
here is letting the rbt know how big the cache can grown and
pre-allocate the hashtable to be big enough to actually never need to
rehash. This will consume more memory at the start, but since the
size of the hashtable is capped to `1 << 32` (e.g. 4 mio entries), it
will only consume maximum of 32GB of memory for hashtable in the
worst case (and max-cache-size would need to be set to more than
4TB). Calling the dns_db_adjusthashsize() will also cap the maximum
size of the hashtable to the pre-computed number of bits, so it won't
try to consume more gigabytes of memory than available for the
database.
FIXME: What is the average size of the rbt node that gets hashed? I
chose the pagesize (4k) as initial value to precompute the size of
the hashtable, but the value is based on feeling and not any real
data.
For future work, there are more places where we use result of the hash
value modulo some small number and that would benefit from Fibonacci
Hashing to get better distribution.
Notes:
a. A doubly linked list should be used here to speedup the removal of
the entries from the hashtable.
b. https://probablydance.com/2018/06/16/fibonacci-hashing-the-optimization-that-the-world-forgot-or-a-better-alternative-to-integer-modulo/
Both clang-tidy and uncrustify chokes on statement like this:
for (...)
if (...)
break;
This commit uses a very simple semantic patch (below) to add braces around such
statements.
Semantic patch used:
@@
statement S;
expression E;
@@
while (...)
- if (E) S
+ { if (E) { S } }
@@
statement S;
expression E;
@@
for (...;...;...)
- if (E) S
+ { if (E) { S } }
@@
statement S;
expression E;
@@
if (...)
- if (E) S
+ { if (E) { S } }
Also disable the semantic patch as the code needs tweaks here and there because
some destroy functions might not destroy the object and return early if the
object is still in use.
isc_event_allocate() calls isc_mem_get() to allocate the event structure. As
isc_mem_get() cannot fail softly (e.g. it never returns NULL), the
isc_event_allocate() cannot return NULL, hence we remove the (ret == NULL)
handling blocks using the semantic patch from the previous commit.
